$450,000

3 beds2 baths2,296 sqft

Roughly $2,942/mo at 20% down, 6.5% over 30 years, including tax. That is 36% above the $330,000 median across 1,702 homes for sale in Conroe.

5188 Old Castle Way, Conroe, TX

Jay, the GotNest home assistant

What Jay sees in the photos of 5188 Old Castle Way

Written by Jay from this home’s 28 listing photos

This two-story colonial home features a mixed-material exterior with grand columns, a shingle roof, an enclosed sunroom, and a detached two-car garage connected by a covered breezeway. Inside, the living room offers beige walls, beige flooring, built-ins, and a floor-to-ceiling brick fireplace alongside a traditional kitchen with custom medium-wood cabinets, brown granite counters, an island, a double oven, an electric range, and stainless appliances. The interior includes tile and carpet flooring, good natural light, standard ceilings, and a primary bath equipped with a double vanity and a walk-in shower. In fair condition and needing updates, the property sits on a large wooded lot with views of trees, basic landscaping, and a backyard that fits a pool.

Style
Traditional
Ceilings
Standard
Kitchen cabinets
Medium wood
Countertops
Brown
Living area floor
Beige
Living area walls
Beige
Room for a pool
Yes

Facts and features

Built in
1983
HOA
$—
Property tax
$8,000/yr
Price per sqft
$196/sqft

Risk factor

No known risk factors reported for this home.

Features

  • Detached
  • Garage
  • Wood burning
  • Subdivision

Local information

Conroe

See this home on the interactive map with commute times, nearby places, and more.

Explore the map

Schools

  • LAGWAY ELEMENTARY SCHOOLElementary · Willis
  • CALFEE MIDDLE SCHOOLMiddle · Willis
  • WILLIS HIGH SCHOOLHigh · Willis

Price history

Aug 28, 2026Listed for sale$450,000

Common questions about this home

How much does 5188 Old Castle Way cost?

5188 Old Castle Way, Conroe, TX is listed at $450,000, or about $196 per square foot.

How big is 5188 Old Castle Way?

This home has 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms across 2,296 square feet, and was built in 1983.

What are the taxes and HOA fees for 5188 Old Castle Way?

Property tax is $8,000 per year.

What schools serve 5188 Old Castle Way?

5188 Old Castle Way, Conroe, TX is served by LAGWAY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL (Elementary), CALFEE MIDDLE SCHOOL (Middle), WILLIS HIGH SCHOOL (High). The home is zoned to the Willis school district.

Has the price of 5188 Old Castle Way changed?

This listing has 1 recorded price event. It was first listed at $450,000 on Aug 28, 2026. The full history is shown above.

How much a month is 5188 Old Castle Way?

At 20% down on a 6.5% 30-year fixed rate, principal and interest on 5188 Old Castle Way, Conroe, TX come to about $2,275 a month. Adding property tax of about $667 brings the estimate to about $2,942 a month. Insurance is not included.

Is 5188 Old Castle Way priced above or below the Conroe median?

$450,000 is about 36% above the $330,000 median list price across the 1,702 homes for sale in Conroe, TX. The comparable homes below run $289,995 to $310,000.

Is 5188 Old Castle Way still available?

Yes — 5188 Old Castle Way, Conroe, TX is currently listed for sale on GotNest.

Listed by Ashley Gibson · Hutson Realty Partners · MLS #TREC#0728676 · Source: HAR

Similar properties